Who are your top 3 for each character? They can be from any cast, past or present. You don't have to have seen them in person. Here are mine:

Elphaba
1. Idina
2. Eden
3. Stephanie

Glinda
1. Kristin
2. Kate
3. Laura

Elphaba
1.) Idina
2.) Steph.
3.) Ana

Glinda
1.) JLT
2.) Kendra
3.) Kristin

1. steph
2. idina
3. eden


1. kendra
2. kristin
3. jlt

Elphaba:
1. Steph
2. Idina
3. Eden

Or, when I'm feeling diplomatic:

1. Steph and Idina
2. Eden
3. Ana or Kristy


Glinda:
1. Kristin
2. Kendra
3. Hilty

When I'm feeling diplomatic about the Glindas, I just lump them all together... no ranks--they're all great and I don't have to judge!

Elphaba
1. Idina
2. SJB
3. Eden*

Glinda
1. Kristin
2. Katie Adams
3. Sarah Jane Everman

* I haven't seen her, but I have heard her singing DG, and it is good.

Elphaba
1. Idina
2. Shoshana
3. Eden

Glinda
1. Megan
2. Kristin
3. Kate or JLT

G(a)linda:
1: Cheno
2: Hilty
3: ...possibly Kendra

Elphaba:
1: Idina
2: Sho
3: Eden

Galinda:
~ Cheno
~ JLT
~ Hilty

Elphaba
This one is hard...
I'll do it some other time

These are in random order because I haven't seen all of them live...

Elphaba:
-Ana
-Idina
-Eden

G(a)linda:
-Cheno
-Hilty
-Kate

Elphaba
Stephanie
Shoshana
Idina

Glinda
Kristen
Megan
Kendra

I cannot rank fairly, but since I feel like ranking, I shall. lol. Of course it's not gonna be fair cuz they're all equal in talent!

Elphaba:
1. Ana (wow, what a shocker)
2. Stephanie
3. Idina

Glinda:
1. Kristin
2. Megan
3. Kate (holy sh*t! I didn't put a chicago cast member first! the world must be coming to an end!)

Wow...This is a no brainer for me...I thought my opinion would be more widely shared but it's not. Interesting how we all perceive the actors/actresses differently.

Elphaba:
1. Idina Menzel
2. Kristy Cates
3. Stephanie J. Block

Glinda:
1. Kristin Chenoweth
2. Megan Hilty
3. Katie Adams

1. Idina
2. Steph
3. Jenna

1. Kristin
2. Emily
3. JLT

Elphabas:

1. Idina
2. Eden
3. Kristy

G(a)lindas:

1. Kristin
2. Megan
3. JLT

Elphaba:

1. Idina
2. Maria
3. Steph

Glinda:

1. Kristin
2. Megan
3. Kendra

Elphaba:

1. Steph or Sho (I really can't decide!!! I have a debate with my mom over who's better everyday! haha)
2. Idina
3. Eden (I haven't seen or heard her as Elphaba, but I love her singing, Once Upon A Time)

Glinda:

1. Cheno!!
2. Kendra
3. Megan

Elphaba:
Idina
Ana
Eden

Glinda:
Kristin
Kate
Kendra

ok have to put this....

top 2 Fiyero's:
Norby *swoon*
Joey

My selections....


Elphaba

Idina
Stephanie
Shoshana*

*-I really need to try and see a bootie, if one exists, of her when she made the role hers, not of the one just after Idina got hurt


Glinda

Kristen
Kendra
JTL

I agree

1. Idina
2. Eden
3. Shoshana

1. Kristen
2. Megan
3. not really sure...Kendra

Elphaba
Saycon
Idina
(I'm guessing either Ana or Eden, haven't seen them yet. Definitely not Sho)

Glinda
Kristin
tie between Megan and JLT

Elphaba:
Idina
Ana!
Stephanie

Glinda:
Cheno!
Kate
JLT

Elphaba:

1. Ana!
2. Sho or Steph, I cannot choose which I prefer XD
3. Idina

Glinda:

1. Cheno!
2. Megan
3. Kate

Elphaba Glinda


Stephanie Block Kristin

Idina Kendra


Shoshana Megan Hilty

oops. i goofed . o well.

Elphies
1. Stephanie J. Block
2. Shoshana Bean
3. Idina Menzel/Jenna Leigh Green
(4. CEJ...but no one knows about her and I suppose she doesn't really count but I had to put her. )

Glindas
1. Kristin Chenoweth
2. Kendra Kassabaum
3. Megan Hilty

Elphaba

1) Steph
2) Idina
3) Eden


Glinda

1) Kendra
2) Kristen
3) JLT

Nessarose (I know this wasn't on here..but w/e)

1) Jenne Leigh Green
2) Michelle Federer
3) TBA

Who who who!?

Elphie:
1:Idina
2:Steph
3:Jenna (Leigh Green)

G(a)linda:

1:Kendra
2:Kristin
3: Megan

Elphaba:
1. Jenna (there's a shocker)
2. Shoshana
3. ???

Glinda:
1. Megan
2. Emily
3. Kristin

She's just a friend of mine...who is AMAZING!! She has her own version of Defying Gravity and she's just really cool and she's going to college to be in theater and hopefully someday Broadway and she has no idea that I've mentioned her and I hope that she's not a part of this site because she'll probably get mad at me... :fryingpan:

:ha:

Tell her to keep singing!

Everyday...I tell her and remind her of her gift and pray for her.

Elphaba:
1. Stephanie
2. Jenna
3. Idina

Glinda:
1. JLT
2. Katie
3. Kristin

Elphaba......
3) Ana
2) Idina
1) SHO!!!!!! (gotta love the riffs)


Glinda......
3) SML
2) Kristin
1) Megan

Elphaba
1. Idina
2. Shoshana
3. Stephanie

Glinda (I only have 2)
1. Kristin
2. Megan Hilty

ELPHABA:
1. SHO!!
2. EDEN
3. IDINA

GLINDA:
1. MEGAN
2. CHENO
3. JLT

Elphaba
1. Stephanie
2. Idina
3. Sho

Glinda
1. Kristin
2. Katie Adams
3. Megan

1 <3 Idina
2 <3 Eden
3 <3 Ana

1 <3 KRISTIN!!!!
2 <3 Megan
3 <3 JLT

Elphies:
-Idina
-Eden
-Sho

Glindas:
-Kristin
-JLT
-Kendra

Elphie:
Idina
Shoshana
SJB

Glinda/Galinda:
Kristin
Megan
JLT

Elphaba
1. Steph
2. Eden
3. Kristy

G(a)linda
1. Kate Reinders
2. Katie Adams
3. Jennifer Laura Thompson

(I've never heard some of the Glindas so please excuse ignorance on that. However, I do believe I've heard every Elphaba)

Elphaba:

1) Idina
2) Eden
3) Saycon

Glinda:

1) Kristen
2) Laura Bell Bundy
3) JLT

Hmmmm not a whole lot of Shoshana fans I see haha.

I'm going to totally break the rules and just say:

Elphaba:
1. Shoshana

Glinda:
1. Megan

I just think those two are so perfect for the roles. I'm sure it helps that it's who I saw. But I honestly haven't seen anyone else that I really care for (don't hurt me!).

1. Ana (no question about it)
2. Idina
3. Shoshana

1. Kristin Chenoweth
2. Kate Reinders
3????

Yay for whoever forgot to sign in and put LBB. Thats my girl, crazy contreversies and all. :mrgreen:

Mine is Really is Stephanie j block

I put her as my 3rd choice. Laura was my first Glinda, so she has a special place in my heart.

Elphabas:
1. Shoshana
2. Idina
3. Saycon

G(a)lindas:
1. Megan
2. Kristen
3. JLT