Has anyone seen Eden as Elphaba yet? Post your reviews here! :elphie3:

I saw her in June 2004. *Much* better than Sho!

I love Sho's riffs, so I am gonna say Eden isn't quite there yet. But Eden has had a veru long time to work with her part, so I hope she had improved tons! Maybe she will have some riffs!!!

Well, I'm seeing Eden in June and I heard she is really awesome!!! :humpy:

I've not seen her (::cough cough: but from what I've heard (::hack hack: I like her more than Shoshana.

HERESY! (sp)

Hey hey, to each her own... and if I wanted to be really picky I'd call "heresy" on those who say Sho is better than Idina (or Steph, for that matter)! We all like different people, and that's cool. ForGood was just giving her opinion.

I have an IDEA: let's make this thread the official Eden review thread. Everyone who sees her should update with a review and pics and stuff. It'll cut down on all the clutter, and it'd be a great place for feedback.

Hey, I'm allowed that think that Sho wasn't great. To each their own.

Ditto that!! :mrgreen:

And, also, ditto the fact that it's a personal choice! Sho and Eden have very different styles so they appeal to different people. Apples and oranges. *feels like a broken record*

hmmm...cough cough..is someone sick? lol!

just playin...its funny when ppl do that!

Yes, I am sick. I am dreadfully sick. I have a fever, and the only prescription is... MORE EDEN!

:rock:

I have only heard eden once(WaI), but i love everyone! everyone is so different and has their own take on Elphie. i love the variety

I've seen Eden twice in San Fran. She was phenomonal both times. :rock: I voted that she is better than Sho. That might just be because I'm on an Eden streak though... :bow:

Ditto!

I've now seen Eden 2.5 times and I love her! Broadway really needed this! The show was getting stale and I was so tired of Shoshana's attitude. I love the girl but she wasn't in it for the right reasons. The show just needed to be revived and on Eden's first night it really showed that it got what it needed:)

GO SHO! But eden is still really good

I agree, SHo was in it for the wrong reasons, and she tended to be a bad sport about it. Im glad we have a new Elphie EDEN rocks!

I saw a video of her Wizard and I, I <3ed it!!It was so good, I might getto see her in March!!

Eden's voice is amzing! haha, I can see there aren't many sho lovers on this board. personally, I think sho is OVER RATED!

i hope she good cuz im going 2 see it for the first time in feb and i don't want it to stink...but itz wicked so it can't :ha:

Alright guys lets not make this the sho-bashing thread

I love Sho and I think she loved Wicked and was in it for the right reasons. Eden will also be great....They both bring unique aspects to the show

i don't really like sho's voice....but i absalutely love her riffs, nobody can riff like her. her voice is perfect for riffing. and she has improved majorly since 1/9/05...and eden has some riffs, and i really like the sound of her voice. she reminds me of idina...*sigh..dee* i hope i get to see her!

Sho rocks! I was :wowie: during her DG, he rifts make the song that much better, plus she was my 1st Elphie, and my 2nd fav. I've never heard Eden but i REALLY want 2, i will probably see her live this summer.

I hope to see her in the fall, if she's still going to be there. HOPEFULLY!!

I saw her on her opening night at the Gershwin! She's incredible! I chose other, because I love both her and Shoshana equally. They both do things their own way and its very cool. Eden plays Elphaba to be a lot more emotional. its amazing.

but can we stop the sho-bashing? I know everyone has their own opinions, but some things people are saying are kind of mean. :-(