Sorry if a poll has already been made on this topic...but if there was, I never saw it, and I'm curious what you all think.

Humor me okay :ha:

I say Idina for all together Elphiness, but Sho is the best singing Elphaba.

Shoshana!!!!!!!!!!!!!

SHO ROCKS!!! :rock:

She will always be my only Elphie

-Katie :wicked:

idina will ALWAYS be my elphie :heart: IDINA LOVE!!! :rock:

woot! :agree:

1. Idina
2. Eden
3. Shoshana

I felt that Sho acted the part better than Idina. But, I just love them both!

yes yes! spread the Idina love!
Idina is definitely my favorite Elphaba, but Sho was awesome too, and I've yet to see Eden.

I said Idina, but it makes me sad that Eden has NO votes! She's veryveryvery close to being my favorite.

Shoshana is the best!

ktnxbye

spread the idina love oh yea oh yea!!! :heart: :heart: :heart:

:agree: poor eden! i think shes amazing too! idinas just my fav!
1. idina
2. eden
3. sho

aww...poor Eden...she sounds so amazing.. :? but maybe there just aren't enough people who have seen her already...

I have to go with my girl IDINA :mrgreen:

Stephanie! Oh...wait. Erm...Idina, then. :mrgreen:

Shoshana all the way!! Shoshana = Love!! Shoshana = :heart:
then Eden is like half a hair behind her!!! I LOVE LOVE LOVE her!! I saw her on her opening night!!
As much as I love Idina in Rent, I'm not too crazy about her Elphie. JMO, don't kill me! I still love you Dee!

TEAM SHOSHANA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!



LOL


Jazz

Again... I refuse to vote

Idina. Closely followed by Sho

Shoshana by a huge margin, but then Stephanie J. Block is really incredible, and I've heard only amazing things about Eden...so if I had to put an order to it it would be

1) Shoshana
2) Stephanie
3) Eden
4) Idina
5) Ana

i only saw Idina so i said Idina... i lover her

Idina's just so pleasant to watch and hear, and I enjoy her the most out of those three ladies, so I voted for her. But (and this is going to be a shock to some people) Shoshana seemed to be the most consistent in both acting and singing. Idina's strength lies in her voice, so when it faltered, her acting wasn't enough to make up for it. Eden seems to be the same way, but I haven't seen her act yet. So Shoshana's the best all around, even if I don't particularly care for her riffing and rock star attitude (which, to be fair, didn't start until the end of her run).

Shoshana

Idina no questions asked.

1) Shoshana
2) Eden
3) Idina

*prepares for war from the Idina lovers* haha

Shoshana all the way!

Sho+Mego all the way!!

Sho, Sho, Rocks My Boat,
When She's Painted Green!
Merrily, Merrily, Merrily, Merrily,
Go Shoshana Bean!

Shoshana, she was my first Elphie and was amazing! followed up by Idina, she is very good and I still love Idina. Lastly Eden, I have heard her but, she isn't as good as Sho and Idina!