Well I've only seen Steph...so Steph!

1. Kristy(she was my first)
2. Dee(back in her standby days)

Only Saycon for me, but that 1 time made me really love her, wheras I didn't at all before.

1. Shoshana/Julia~~I can't choose
2. Victoria
3. Ana
4. Eden

1. Dee
2. Ana

Yeah. I love them both, but Dee takes the cake for me.

1. Stephanie
2. Maria
3. Shoshana
4. Kristy
5. Eden

Stephanie is very much in the lead.

Whereas Shoshana was very talented, it was really her chemistry with Megan that made the show moreso than her individual performance, and Maria is such a sweetheart and, IMO, more honest with the role (can't have the frosting without any cake), so she claimed number two, but Shoshana is a very close third.

Kristy and Eden are relatively tied. As unfair as this may seem, Kate really ruined it for me in New York (I understand its personal preference, and I 100% respect others liking her portrayal, but I didn't so much), so that sort of lowered what I thought of Eden. From other things (she sang TWAI somewhere, legally, which is on YouTube, and in Brooklyn, of course) I do really like her, so I'm hoping LA will allow me to appreciate her more.

I have seen many of the Elphaba's and I must say they are all number one in my book. But if I had to pick one that was a little more of my fave it would be Idina.

1.Victoria

and you know what funny, when I see the tour in juen, I'll see her again!

1. Eden
2. Julia
3. Kristy
4. Victoria
5. Maria
6. Saycon

1. Dee
2. Maria

1. Eden!
2. Saycon

1) Eden
2) Victoria
3) Dee
4) Stephanie J Block

1. Stephanie

2. Julia

3. Idina

4. Eden

5. Victoria

6. Sho

Note the first four are really close!

1 . Idina

only one ive seen but i dont care , she was brilliant :-)

1. Kerry Ellis
2. Idina Menzel
3. Cassidy Janson

1)Cassidy Janson/Kerry Ellis (can't choose)

3)Shona White/Idina Menzel (again...can't choose)

1) Kerry Ellis
1) Cassidy Janson

(yes they are both #1...im bad at making decisions!)

1. Stephanie J. Block

2. Eden Espinosa

3. Victoria Matlock

(hopefully I can add Julia to the list)

This is an OLD topic. My opinions have changed since last time I posted.

1) Idina Menzel











2) Kerry Ellis
3) Shoshana Bean
4) Eden Espinosa

1. Shoshana Bean
2. Victoria Matlock
3. Julia Murney

You know whats wierd...the day this thread was revived was its 1 year anniversary. haha.

darn. I can't do this!! I've never seen the show!! :cry: :disagree: :ha:

1. Idina Menzel (in London). It was the best performance of anything I've ever seen in my entire life.




2. Julia Murney (On tour I didn't like her..on broadway she was a lot better)

1.Idina
2.Shoshana
3.Dee
4.Eden

this is really hard to do.. they're all really close
1. Saycon
2. Idina
3. Victoria

1. Julia Murney
2. Eden Espinosa

1) Victoria Matlock
2) Victoria Matlock

She's amazing. Blew me away in both Boston and Providence. Plus, she's my first and only Elphie so far :mrgreen:

1. Idina!!!!!!! (She IS Elphie to me. She just IS. 7 times in a week wasn't nearly enough! I regret the 3 shows that week I didn't see. And I regret the 1 out of 7 shows that I didn't sit in the front row for. She has the most amazing facial expressions! And her stage presence?... BLOWS MY MIND.)

2. Shoshana

1. Kristy Cates
2. Saycon Sengbloh

(If I had seen more Elphabas live, then Saycon would be wayyyy down at the bottom. She ruined to show for me.)

1] Shoshana Bean [and I've seen her 3 times =D]
2] Victoria Matlock [she's very close behind Sho. She's amazing.]

EDEN ESPINOSA! :rock:

1- idina menzel
2- julia murney
3- ana gastyer

i saw idina first, then ana then julia. julia blew me away. i didn' think anyone could be as good a idina. ana didn't do it for me. no offense meant to anyone who disagrees!

1- idina menzel
2- julia murney
3- ana gastyer

i saw idina first, then ana then julia. julia blew me away. i didn' think anyone could be as good a idina. ana didn't do it for me. no offense meant to anyone who disagrees!

1- Eden Espinosa
2- Stephanie J Block
3- Jenna Leigh Green

1.Stephanie J. Block
2. Victoria and Eden
3. Maria very closley behind.
4. Shoshana very far behind (please don't shoot!

1. Jennifer DiNoia!!! :rock:

1. Shoshana Bean
2. Stephanie J. Block
3. Maria Eberline

However, I'll have to rerank in about a month after I see Victoria and Coleen.

1. Idina Menzel
2. Shona White
3. CJ
4. Kerry Ellis

I think where i sat played a part. I'd love to see Kerry again from closer up.

1.Victoria Matlock!!!
2. Brandi Chavvone Massey

I've only seen Ana live, so she's number 1. Hopefully I'm seeing Julia and Victoria really soon!

1. Shoshana Bean
2. Victoria Matlock/Coleen Sexton (the first three times)
3. Marcie Dodd/Coleen Sexton (the last time)
4. Stephanie Block
5. Maria Eberline

But I loved them all

1. Stephanie J. Block
2. Kerry Ellis
3. Idina Menzel
4. Eden Espinosa
5. Victoria Matlock
6. Julia Murney
7. Kristy Cates

Well, Eden Espinosa will always be my #1 one favorite no matter how many Elphies i've seen. She is my first and i want to see more! I really wanna see Julie!

1. Idina Menzel
2. Eden Espinosa
3. Ana Gasteyer
4. Dee Roscioli
5. Maria Eberline

It's very close between Dee and Maria. I think Maria is a better actress and Dee is a better singer, but I put Dee first because I really liked her NGD.

Mine's changed so:

1. Idina Menzel
2. Kerry Ellis
3. Shona White
4. Cassidy Janson

They're all very very close though.

Eden =]

Kerry
Idina
Cj
Lisa

It's all SO unbelievably close...

1. Shona White
2. Idina Menzel
3. Kerry Ellis

And I've still yet to see CJ :-( And I hopefully will see Julia later in the year :-)

1. Shona White
1a. Kerry Ellis
2. Idina Menzel

1) Kristy Cates
2) Ana Gastyer